top of page

Standing Out in the Crowd: The Online Review Advantage for Insurance Agents

The image is an illustrative graphic with a central theme of online reviews for insurance agents. The top section of the image has a title that says "Standing Out in the Crowd: The Online Review Advantage for Insurance Agents" in orange and black text against a light background with a subtle grey pattern. Below the title is a circular logo with the word "BLOG." The graphic features a hand holding a smartphone with chat bubbles on the screen, symbolizing messages or reviews, and there are icons indicating likes, dislikes, and comments.  Beside the smartphone, there are three speech bubbles, each containing a customer review with a 5-star rating at the top. The first review says "Great customer service" and praises the patience of the person who helped set up an auto policy. The second review states "Saved tons of $" and expresses gratitude for the money saved by switching to the agency. The third review is titled "Always quick to respond" and compliments the agency for being prompt in responding over a five-year relationship.  The overall image is designed to convey the importance of positive online reviews and customer feedback for insurance agents to distinguish themselves from competitors.

Potential customers are increasingly turning to online reviews to gauge the credibility and reliability of which insurance agency they want to work with. In this post, we'll delve into the crucial role of online reviews and offer insights into how to easily garner new reviews for your business.

The Importance of Reviews:

Credibility and Trust: When people are making the decision to work with your agency or the one down the road, they will almost always choose one with a hundred positive reviews over another with a few reviews scattered over the past five years. 

Competitive Advantage: To show up for popular searches like “Auto Insurance,” “Home Insurance,” or “Insurance Agent” you need a robust SEO strategy. Reviews play a huge role in improving your SEO ranking and help you “win” these generic insurance searches. 

Consistency and Quantity: You want a consistent stream of new reviews coming in to help your agency’s long-term SEO efforts. A high volume of positive reviews can also help drown out those one-off negative reviews. 

Monitoring: By actively engaging with reviews and showcasing thanking people for their feedback, good or bad, your agency stands out as being receptive to customers. Everyone wants to feel listened to, and this is a great way to show them how your agency listens to customers. 

How to Get Reviews:

Team motivation: Consider building review goals into your compensation plans. You can require one or more reviews per month to hit a team or personal bonus or a flat bonus per new review.

Customer Outreach: Send a thank you text with a review link to every customer you sign up. You can also reach out after every IFR or policy review for customers who were pleased. 

Visibility: Create a QR code and have it laminated at your desk so people can quickly scan and leave a review with their smartphones. To get more attention on it, put a candy bowl next to it. Everyone loves free candy.

Friends and Family: Ask the people who love and support you most! Since consistency is key, reach out to one or two people each month and stagger your requests so you always can count on at least a few new reviews each month.

Your business’s reputation is invaluable. By consistently receiving and engaging with reviews, your insurance agency can cultivate a robust and trustworthy online reputation that sets you apart, especially in the competitive insurance industry.


bottom of page